A recently released statewide study by researchers from California State University, Sacramento, provides an idea of how difficult it is for students to graduate and what improvements can be made to the system.
The “Divided We Fail” study, begun in 2003 by the Institute for Higher Education Leadership & Policy, examined the records of over 250,000 California community college students. The study found that only about 30 percent of students had received diplomas, certificates or had transferred to a university after six years. This “erosion in education” was reported throughout the state and has set off much debate in the higher education community over both its findings and methods.
Marybeth Buechner, City College dean of Planning, Research and Institutional Effectiveness, said she has read the study and questions some of its methods. She is particularly concerned with the study’s decision to count students enrolled in over six units in their first year as a “degree-seeking” student.
“I believe [the study’s] rates are artificially low because the denominator is artificially high,” Buechner said, referring to the number of overall students used to determine the 30 percent graduation rate. “I disagree with the denominator they used. I think they don’t fully understand our system.”
While graduation rate estimates vary widely — some as high as 50 percent and others as low as single digits, depending on criteria — the fact remains that the road to graduation or transfer is difficult for many students.
“Divided We Fail” found that community college success was especially difficult to achieve for minority and low income students, along with those who enrolled as less than full-time students or did not take college level English or math in their first year.
“The majority of our students are part time,” said Buechner. “I think a lot of individuals have financial challenges. Some students don’t have the academic background and preparation. There are an awful lot of reasons why our students aren’t as successful as they could possibly be.”
In brief interviews on the City College campus, students revealed a variety of personal obstacles to graduating
that was as diverse as the student body itself. Some difficulties included getting into required classes, changes in requirements, time conflicts, expenses, indecision and lack of confidence in their skills, according to students.
The readiness of students to transfer to four-year institutions is another area of concern, according to the study. It found that less than half of transferees had completed a transfer curriculum with 60 credits, a UC and CSU school requirement, and only about one-fourth earned an associate degree. This meant that most students who transferred were doing so to out-of-state, private or for-profit colleges.
The study offers several policy suggestions that the authors believe can boost California’s community college success rates. This included offering students a more effective orientation and better college success courses, in addition to forming learning
communities for basic skills students and transfer advising that emphasizes course progression.
California’s community colleges have been called the largest higher education system in the world and a cornerstone in the American community college system, and have been the recent subject of a White House Summit and $35 million grant from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. Much emphasis is being placed on community colleges’ ability to better prepare
citizens for the future or be confronted with, as “Dived We Fail” states, an “adverse impact on the workforce, tax base and quality of life in California.”
Richard Yang, transfer center director at City College— where 1,692 students graduated in 2008-09, according to data available in the college’s Fact Book — believes that broader elements that have contributed to the current situation.
“The economy is a big factor — that and persistence,” said Yang. “This is why some populations in society are under-represented.”
Sac City Express
Latest posts by Sac City Express (see all)
- City College makerspace to provide open lab; Weld, print 3-D objects, make art or music in collaborative space - June 4, 2017
- Paul Gutierrez: City College student prepares to be the model he never had as a child - May 26, 2017
- Blair Lynch: Youth doesn’t mean inexperience for psychology professor - May 23, 2017